---

name: skill-reviewer description: "Review skill PRs with structured severity-rated feedback covering token budgets, routing conflicts, required sections, and repo conventions. WHEN: "review skill", "review skill PR", "review skill changes", "check skill quality", "skill PR feedback"." license: MIT metadata: author: Microsoft version: "1.0.3"

Skill PR Reviewer

Performs thorough, structured code reviews of skill PRs — severity-classified findings with actionable fixes, positive acknowledgment, and a summary table.

When to Use

• Reviewing a PR that adds or modifies a skill under plugin/skills/ or .github/skills/
• Checking skill compliance before submitting a PR
• Auditing an existing skill for quality issues

💡 Note: .github/skills/ meta-skills have different conventions — checklist sections 8-9 apply only to plugin/skills/ service skills.

Review Workflow

1. Collect — Identify all changed skill files (SKILL.md, references, tests, scripts)
2. Check — Run each category from the review checklist
3. Classify — Assign severity per the severity guide
4. Analyze Routing — Check triggers for conflicts per routing analysis
5. Draft — Write the review per the output format
6. Validate — Verify suggested fixes are actionable with accurate file/line references

Error Handling

Error	Remediation
Cannot determine changed files	Ask user for the file list or PR number
Token counting unavailable	Estimate at ~4 chars per token

References

• Review Checklist
• Severity Classification
• Routing Analysis
• Output Format